Dec 22 2010
A Lump of Coal for Daily Candy’s Sweet Little Lies
We’ve remarked in amazement this year on how so many Americans have gotten the wrong idea about what the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) is—and what it isn’t. (Reader’s Digest version: It’s a richer version of PETA, and it’s not connected with your local Humane Society.)
The folks at the popular “Daily Candy” website don’t seem to get it. (Or maybe they do, and they just don’t care about animals all that much.) Yesterday’s DailyCandy Deals e-mail included a sugar-coated little promo for HSUS, titled “Comfort of Creatures.”
Here’s how they set it up (emphasis in the original):
The Humane Society saves puppies (and kitties, birds, turtles, chinchillas, etc.), and if you can’t give one a home for the holidays (and forever after that), give some green to help the cause.
Did you catch that? “The” Humane Society? Like there’s only one. And it apparently “saves puppies.”
That’s a neat trick, since “The” Humane Society (of the United States) doesn’t run any pet shelters. You know—the kind with puppies (and kitties).
Play the tape forward—click on the Daily Candy link—and the syrup starts tasting even more like saccharine (emphasis added):
The Humane Society is more than just an adoption agency and shelter. It works to protect animals by pushing for better laws, investigating animal cruelty, encouraging pet-friendly policies, and conducting disaster relief and animal rescue. We’re big fans and think you should be, too.
Donate online at humanesociety.org.
Really, now? This is about as meaningful as saying your kitchen blender is “more than just a bowling alley on wheels.” Sure, it can chop, blend, and frappé, but if you're facing a seven-ten split, it's not much use.
Notice the cute kittens in the Daily Candy article? Those are the kittens that wind up dead because the shelter they're living in is dirt poor and has to euthanize more cats than it adopts out. It's under-funded because HSUS sucks gazillions of dollars out of its community and shares hardly any of it with the shelter that the donors thought they were funding.
Yeah. Those kittens.
Let’s set the record straight, yet again, since HSUS’s factory-fundraising operation has no interest in doing so. The Humane Society of the United States is nothing like “an adoption agency and shelter.”
There are thousands of hands-on pet shelters in America; somewhere between one-third and one-half of them have the words “Humane Society” in their names. If you’re into bankrolling Fido’s lobbyists and HSUS’s many defense lawyers, more power to you (and to them). But let’s not pretend HSUS regularly shelters pets or adopts them out.
That’s actual grunt work. The hard kind that HSUS CEO Wayne Pacelle has never done, and probably never will. It’s thankless work that can’t be supervised from a sprawling fundraising complex in Maryland. You get the picture.
The Daily Candy should embark on a tour of America’s real Humane Societies—and then reconsider the wisdom of telling Americans that there’s only one worthwhile way to support animals during the holiday season.
Related Organizations
Comments
This upsets me greatly. People really should donate to the local shelters and rescue groups. They really need the money more than PeTA and the HSUS ever will.
Here is a link to send an email to DailyCandy:
http://www.dailycandy.com/contact.jsp
It took me a bit of digging to find it. I do not want to have to create an account to be able to contact them.
AMEN!!! I’ve worked at a local shelter for eight years. I am one of the grunts who does the cleaning, the sheltering and unfortunately the euthanasias. The HSUS is not affiliated with us. If you donate to them, we don’t see a dime of it. People need to support their local shelters. If you can’t donate money, you can donate supplies, If you can’t do that, you can always donate your time. If you don’t like your shelter, then you need to change it. Giving money to a bloated organization like the HSUS will not change your community, you giving to your local shelter will.
The phrase “The Humane Society is more than just an adoption agency and shelter” clearly implies that the HSUS actually IS a pet adoption agency and shelter - plus more, To interpret that correctly, one would have to know already that what HSUS does is *instead of* taking care of pets rather than *in addition to*- which it does not do. The phrase does not explain, it overtly misleads. This misdirection is so well crafted, I’d bet that it comes directly from the spin-staff at HSUS. Any takers?
Advocacy is more important than direct care. Both are necessary, but in the long run, advocacy helps more animals.
@ Dixie’s Mom. Thanks for the email link!
“Advocacy is more important than direct care. Both are necessary, but in the long run, advocacy helps more animals”
Translation: It’s OK to let pets die in shelters when they could so easily be saved if HSUS would loosen its wallet - but screw them - the LAWS we “must pass” are more important than any REAL hands-on work.
Are you in the employ of HSUS Dan? Sarah can’t possibly say stupid things like what you just said to HSUS critics at every hour of the day - that kind of a job needs more than one person to do. Effectively*.
*For a given definition of.
Comments are moderated, and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. Extremely lengthy comments and those that contain obscenities may be edited before they are posted.
Add a comment:
I am appalled.