Apr 06 2010

HSUS Gets Cracking in Iowa (Here We Go Again)

An HSUS "Media Advisory" came to our e-mail a half-hour ago. Here's what the group is planning for tomorrow:

FOR PLANNING PURPOSES
MEDIA ADVISORY
Humane Society of the United States to Release New Undercover Investigations Revealing Rampant Cruelty at Egg Factory Farms

WHAT: Press conference to announce The Humane Society of the United States’ latest undercover investigations into major egg producers. The HSUS will release video footage revealing appalling suffering at multiple egg factory farms and outline critically-needed reforms in animal agribusiness. The HSUS will also release a new report detailing the problems inherent in cage confinement of laying hens and the importance of the national movement toward cage-free production systems.
WHO: Wayne Pacelle, president and CEO of The HSUS
WHERE: Des Moines Marriott Downtown, 700 Grand Avenue, Des Moines, Iowa
Or by teleconference. RSVP to Erin Williams, 301-721-6446 or ewilliams@humanesociety.org
WHEN: 10:00am CST, Wednesday, April 7

Media contact: Erin Williams, 301-721-6446, ewilliams@humanesociety.org

Is anyone surprised? Not us. It's an election year, after all, and HSUS is crusading against egg farmers.

If you were planning to rush out the door to Des Moines, don't go. We'll save you the cost of a plane ticket. Here's what you'll likely be subjected to tomorrow. We've also written a few press-conference questions that we sure wish someone would ask.

The scene will open with the bronze-tanned Wayne Pacelle sticking out like a sore thumb among pale Iowans who don't have expense accounts like his.

We will hear about how horrible egg farms are. We'll see no more than five minutes of video, probably in 30-second snippets, and probably shot over a period of three to four months.

We will not see uncut videos, and we will not see any evidence that farmers and their hired hands worked to correct whatever problems are depicted in the movies. Any reporter who asks whether or not the unedited video will be made available will get a crash-course in how to change the subject.

Pacelle will declare that the only way to avoid treating hens "with unconscionable cruelty" is to start raising all eggs in cage-free systems. And he'll throw in a plug for HSUS's Ohio ballot initiative, which promises to enforce just such a standard on farmers whether they like it or not.

We will not hear anything about scientific studies showing that cage-free egg production results in higher mortality for egg-laying hens and a greater risk of disease from several pathogens. We will not hear about how cage-free egg systems cost jobs.

We also will not see Wayne Pacelle eat an omelet. Not even a cage-free one. We kinda hope some enterprising young reporter brings him one. Just to see if he'll prove me wrong.

Here's my wish-list of questions, in case you know a reporter who will be attending:

  1. Mr. Pacelle, are you really saying that every large egg farm is a horrible Nazi death-camp, and that every small, backyard operation is the very picture of bucolic splendor?
  2. Mr. Pacelle, if I bring you an omelet right now, and promise that the eggs were from hens that enjoyed their own salad bar, daily wing-rubdowns, iPad privileges, and suites at the Ritz, will you eat it?
  3. Mr. Pacelle, since a New Zealand study showed that hen mortality is higher in free-range egg systems, aren't you advocating for the needless death of countless chickens? How exactly is that "humane"?
  4. Mr. Pacelle, have you ever actually seen an egg? Other than in the HSUS screening room, I mean.
  5. Mr. Pacelle, how many thousands of jobs do you think a national switch to cage-free egg production would cost the U.S. economy? Are you willing to hire all of those people at HSUS? (No, they won't necessarily bogart the pension plan.)
  6. Mr. Pacelle, who held the camera while your undercover investigators rushed to help the distressed chickens? I mean, surely they intervened to help the animals, right? Mr. Pacelle?

Hey—we can dream...

Posted on 04/06/2010 at 03:39 PM by the HumaneWatch Team

Animal AgricultureEggs • (6) Comments

Share

Comments 

My favorite questions are #3, I’d add my two studies and make sure I had copies of all pass out!  I also would love to ask about question #6 and ask him to relate the study to the investigation of PLA by New Mexico Land board!

Thank you for study number three in my collection, all with the same results!

Posted by Kim on 04/06 at 04:28 PM

Dang it!  I have to work or I’d be down there with a Humane Watch placard.  Might even make it a sandwich board and wear my pasties like the PETA folk (and the upside to that is the camera people wouldn’t need extra lighting, my lily white bod would provide enough wattage).

Posted by Bobbie on 04/06 at 04:33 PM

Eggs.  Hmmm.  I see a mandatory spay/neuter bill coming.

Posted by john galt on 04/06 at 04:58 PM

Ok, I have a question that I have always wondered? Why won’t vegans eat eggs. A chicken has to lay them, she can’t help it and will lay it whether or not it is fertilized. So eating an unfertilized egg doesn’t “kill” a baby chick. It sure doesn’t hurt the chicken (keeping her from laying an egg probably would hurt her) so why not eat eggs. It’s a high protein food that would go to waste if people didn’t eat omelettes!

They can argue (although I disagree) that drinking milk takes away from baby calves or that of course “killing” animals for food is wrong, but this egg thing I don’t understand at all.
BTW - Great questions, which I could be there I’d ask!!

We could also ask Wayne where he gets his tan? Doesn’t he know excessive tanning causes cancer??

Posted by MKBR on 04/06 at 06:27 PM

I don’t WANT cage free eggs (I have seen chickens in non-cage free areas, I know what they do and how they act and what they will pick up to eat even with “good” food available)....same with honey bees FWIW…..I also know what happens to chickens from the other wildlife in an area.

Even in the City of Dallas a neighbor has a chicken at her lovely expensive home (I know not why) but the neighborhood BOBCATS stand around and covet it, she says…..but the coyotes don’t bother her!

Just noticed what my little doofollies say to verify I’m not spam….yikes…..Police Thrives (and I just read the Animal Shelter Minutes to know that while MAC donated 2 digital cameras to the Shelter to take pics of CRUELTY cases and MAC donated $25,000 to pay HSUS for the Shelter evaluation, they can’t pay for more N/S for those who can’t pay for it, right nothing to do with chickens but the cruelty officers went to HSUS U :-D).....they could come after the neighbors BIRD!

Posted by Mary Lou on 04/06 at 06:32 PM

http://www.mikeroweworks.com/2010/02/mike-rowe-egg-farming-its-a-tough-job/
Hope this link goes through with my comment. This is the type of video HSUS does NOT want the public to see. It’s an entirely different world than what is portrayed in an animal rights video. It shows what a large farm is like when following the laws we already have in place. Healthy chickens, clean facilities, and no one treating the birds the way it’s shown by HSUS. What proof does HSUS offer in their videos that they were taken at the facilities they claim they were? What proof do they offer that it isn’t their own paid staff abusing the animals for the purpose of the videos? What scientific evidence do they provide the way Mike Rowe did by talking to professionals in animal care standards to back up their claims?

Posted by Nancy on 04/07 at 03:35 PM

Comments are moderated, and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. Extremely lengthy comments and those that contain obscenities may be edited before they are posted.

Add a comment:

Name:

Email: (will not be displayed)

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

« Back to blog homepage