Aug 19 2010
Humane Society Veterinary Misdirection Association
Daring to say that the vegan emperor has no clothes can be pretty rewarding. As HumaneWatch Nation grows, we've emboldened countless Americans to articulate their fears, doubts, and (sometimes) anger about the Humane Society of the United States. Last week we heard from a pet shelter director. And today's feedback comes from a veterinary student who is asking some tough questions about the "Humane Society Veterinary Medical Association."
It would be interesting to learn whether her concerns represent the thoughts of most U.S. veterinary students, or of just a handful of alert doctors-to-be. We're withholding the author's name at her request.
I am a third year veterinary student and recently attended a SAVMA (Student American Veterinary Medical Association) conference. That's where all the veterinary schools meet to attend lectures and wet labs, learn about new veterinary products, and network between schools.
One thing that caught my attention was the presence of the new HSVMA (Humane Society Veterinary Medical Association), which was marketed to us as taking the place of the RAVS (Rural Area Veterinary Services), which was run by the HSUS. Here is the web page: http://www.ruralareavet.org/
They were eager to let us know that HSUS was no longer part of the program, and they were taking it over, which I was very excited about. I have had friends and professors participate in the RAVS program, and none of them was happy it was sponsored by the HSUS. One of them told me he was happy to take HSUS's money and put it toward spays and neuters instead of politics.
Once I got home and started looking into it, it looks like they just changed the name.
I flipped over the brochure they gave us and there it was. On the bottom, it read "HSUS." On the web page on the bottom there is a red flag to me:
Looking for additional service-learning opportunities? The HSUS Animal Care Centers, a network of sanctuaries and wildlife rehabilitation facilities in MA, FL, CA, TX and OR, provide volunteer opportunities for students to gain exposure to exotic animal care and wildlife rehabilitation while caring for animals in need.
The HSUS is even coming to our veterinary events, trying to get us to join their programs under what looks to me to be false pretenses.
Sincerely,
[name withheld]
This is not the first time we've heard about RAVS promotions making the (false) claim that HSUS is no longer in charge. It almost looks like HSUS understands just how unwelcome its message is among today's veterinarians.
Veterinarians' misgivings may be borne of vets recognizing ulterior motives behind the creation of the HSVMA. (After all, the organization used to be called the "Association of Veterinarians for Animal Rights" before HSUS acquired it.) It might be that the veterinary profession understands that HSUS's long-term agenda involves a shrinking of the American pet population—which isn't exactly good for business. Or it could be that animal doctors, who spend every bit as much time in training as medical doctors (and often more money), resent being preached to by a group of laymen whose leadership includes zero veterinarians.
In any event, the veterinary "establishment" (by which we mean the leadership of the American Veterinary Medical Association) has little patience with HSUS. The AVMA's top doc even poured his views into a YouTube video last year.
At the end of the day, it's unlikely that HSUS, the HSVMA, or the people who promote the RAVS program will be able to convert today's veterinarians into animal rights activists. (Just like it's unlikely that PETA will turn today's adult omnivores into tomorrow's vegetarians). So HSUS is targeting veterinary schools students—the young people whose moral compass isn't yet set in stone. (The parallel with animal rights activists putting curriculum materials into public schools should not be lost on anyone.)
It's all about the next generation. HSUS is going after them. Is the AVMA pushing back in a way that tomorrow's DVM's can see and appreciate? No one we've spoken to seems to know for sure.
Related Organizations
Comments
Yes, Janet, I guess you did.
Janet, I thought I read volunteer, meaning no money from HSUS.
Janet, the Wisconsin DNR got into a lot of hot water, boiling, in fact, by making the mistake of taking HSUS up on one of it’s offers to “do good.” It is a very bad idea to believe that HSUS has animals’—or people’s—best interests in mind. While the public is looking at those pitiful animals in HSUS marketing materials and feeling so very sorry for them, and donating money to help them, the HSUS is doing a lot of damage behind those images. As the vet student noticed, HSUS is famous for operating under false pretenses.
At some point, an organization is so corrupt, or the agenda so twisted, that animal lovers with integrity have no choice but to find more worthy organizations to support. As soon as HSUS has it’s hands on the money it is worthless, as far as I am concerned. It doesn’t take a lot of time to find other effective ways to fight against animal cruelty, from pets to agriculture to wildlife. Petsmart Charities, for example, has a staff of maybe 30 or so, yet they are very effective in helping animals and people in disasters, and transporting pets from high-kill areas to areas where there is a shortage of adoptable animals.
I know people who do wildlife rehabilitation; they are in every state. I don’t think any wildlife rehabber would turn away a vet student looking to volunteer to help out with wildlife in need.
A good friend of mine has been doing wildlife rehab for many years. She has had animals turned over to her by the state for rehab because she has the facilities to securely care for a number of different types of animals. She has had experience with most mammals, from chipmunks to coyotes. She turns over birds or the largest mammals to facilities better qualified to handle them.
Every state has a department of environmental conservation or an equivalent department. All rehabbers would be licensed through that department. To find volunteer opportunities would be as simple as contacting the state agency and asking for a list of state approved agencies and contacting one or more of them directly.
I was lucky enough to find this article and read up on all the controversy. I am new student to the veterinary world and have been doing tons of volunteer work, and now have the ability to followup on new sites to volunteer my time and efforts. I help in a shelter locally and many rescues in the local area and feel that in my area, so many are doing so much to help and funding is never enough. This will always be an issue and that is why we do need to let volunteers help and learn and grow so that we can continue to lessen the effects on animal cruelty everywhere. Thank you all for this information.
What can one do when your pets are seized and promised to be returned to you, you are caught in a distressed situation and you are crying and a piece of paper is given to you to sign. It was a dirty trick to get me to sign a release after being promised the return of my dogs after they were spayed, neutered and given their shots. This was courtesy of the local SPCA. I know I should have read it,but I really felt I was trying to cooperate with them and thought they (SPCA) were being honest me.
Are all the pet organizations monitered? They sure need to be,because the local animal shelters do what they want to citizens and so does the local SPCA. How can an organization be formed to help citizens. We are not all hoarders and one term and the same action should not fit all situtions.
Comments are moderated, and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. Extremely lengthy comments and those that contain obscenities may be edited before they are posted.
Add a comment:

I’m not sure why that paragraph caught the vet student’s attention. Wildlife sanctuaries play a very important role in wildlife rehabilitation, and if I were a vet student, I’d jump at the chance to work in one. Your future as a pet vet is not likely to give you a chance to care for a bald eagle or a great blue heron, but a stint at a sanctuary just might. Seems to me to be a situation where you take HSUS’s money and use it for something intelligent and good-doing. But maybe I’ve missed the point somehow.