Feb 19 2010
You are Now Entering a Meat-Free Zone ...
And now, a few words about being vegan.
Surprise! We don't care if you're "veg." We don't feel the least bit threatened by raw-food vegans who only eat plants harvested in the Southern Hemisphere on alternate Tuesdays. Doesn't bother us a bit.
But we are annoyed to no end by the Humane Society of the United States's habit of denying that it's principally interested in moving Americans toward veganism. We wish Paul Shapiro, Josh Balk, and other HSUS spokespersons would come clean about that.
A few years ago, our research director was asked by some Congressmen to testify before a House Agriculture subcommittee about the federal Farm Bill. And Wayne Pacelle was on the panel with him. (They sat, literally, at opposite ends of the table.)
Here's a little bit of what he said:
Personally, I will believe that HSUS and Farm Sanctuary are in favor of “humane” meat production on the day that their leaders join me in eating it.
I invite Gene Baur, Wayne Pacelle, and Paul Shapiro, for instance, to e-mail me and let me know what they think the most humanely raised veal on the planet is. Dinner is on me. All they have to do is eat it—in front of a few dozen
cameras.I’m confident that I won’t have to buy that meal, because those gentlemen don’t believe such a thing as “humane” meat production can ever exist.
Put another way, imagine that Congress required U.S. farmers to supply every pig, chicken, duck, and cow in all the land with private rooms, daily rubdowns, video iPods, and organic meals catered by Wolfgang Puck himself. What would happen? Would PETA cheerfully pack up its Hollywood rolodex? Would this satisfy Farm Sanctuary or HSUS?
No. They would continue to argue that farm animals have inherent “rights”—and chief among them is the right to not be eaten. Besides, declaring your own obsolescence has a way of drying up donations.
Now, we know what you're thinking: Pacelle and Shapiro are vegans, and it would be wrong to ask them to abandon their beliefs and tuck into a plate of Wiener Schnitzel just to satisfy us. You're right, of course.
But we still think Wayne Pacelle could make a lot of people more comfortable if he would at least endorse a handful of real meat and dairy products. He doesn't have to eat them. Just agree that there is such a thing as humanely produced animal protein.
After all, if HSUS's goal is really just to "eliminate the worst abuses" of livestock farmers (as Wayne is fond of saying), there's got to be someone who's already doing things right.
Right?
So why is it that we never see recipes on the HSUS website that are anything but vegan? Yesterday, HSUS put out some recommendations for Lent. All vegan. Same with their favorite holiday sweets. Even the chocolate cake has no milk and no eggs.
Not even the "cage-free" eggs that HSUS lobbies for. Apparently, if the whole country went "cage-free," HSUS would just count it as one in a long series of First Downs.
Again, if you want to be a vegan and put quote marks around your "chick'n" and "eggs," that's fine with me. What bugs us is the duplicity. If HSUS wants everyone to be vegan, they should come out and say so—in every TV ad and every web page.
You know what that would make them? First of all, honest. And second, it would make them this.
Image: Meat Free Zone
Related Documents
Related People
Related Organizations
Posted on 02/19/2010 at 10:02 AM by the HumaneWatch Team
Animal Agriculture • Dairy • Eggs • Meat • (5) CommentsComments
Jeez, why do they think it is OK to decapitate a lettuce for their sustenance? I kill a duck and it is food. Both organisms have to die to feed us. That is a fact of life. We cannot live n fruit and nuts alone.
Hell, a vegan diet is not even good for humans. Our teeth prove we are obligate omnivores. No true vegan lasts more then 3 years without cheating. They get to a nutritional roadblock that REQUIRES they eat some non-vege foods. They can go back but a kick-starting cheat day is going to be required to live.
Lastly, why do these nut-balls feel it is OK to shove their agenda up my colon? I don’t try to shove mine up theirs. Wayne Pacelle… get a life. A real one of your own, not one bullying others around.
This misconception that all vegans shove agendas is frustrating.
People who follow vegan diets try to do the least harm necessary to other creatures and the earth. (Just read any statistic about factory farming’s effects on the environment and continue to try to call yourself “green”...) Vegans seem to think that vegan diets will not harm creatures? We are all human, no one can achieve the perfect diet in this commerce-based society. But what we can do is do everything in our power, if we actually CARE and look past our own conveniences and desires, to eliminate the harm that we have the choice to either allow into our lives, or eliminate all support for it possible. Yes, there are impossibilities like field animals being harmed in plant agriculture, etc. In an effort to avoid this, most vegans eat local, small-farm harvested, organic plants or grow their own. Knowing what you’re eating and choosing to become aware and conscious of what you eat rather than detached and ignorant comes with other lifestyle changes that are inevitable.
It’s people who cant separate themselves from the only things that they’ve known and are comforted by who halt any possibility of progression. People can’t remove themselves from a tradition that was engrained into them and “tastes good.” A lot of vegans are frustrated because stereotypes have become so unfair and quick to come to those who don’t understand that there is actually a powerful reason for veganism that millions of vegans feel passionate about enough to stand up for. Not millions of the only savage Americans who would choose such a diet, but millions of diverse people who have chosen to educate themselves about diet, choosing to counter the usual “Just eat and don’t think.” (the numbers are growing as awareness increases.)
Of COURSE they are lobbying for cage free eggs. Yes, veganism is ideal, but vegans generally want to lessen impact. Cage free eggs are a huge step away from factory farming. Yes, no eggs is better for health, for animals (could every American who wants to eat eggs really be fed this way? As long as we all demand eggs, factory farming will exist….)
If you are unable to stand back from your own perceptions and see what needs to be changed in the world, no one will get anywhere. That’s why I’m mad that vegans are misunderstood.
Of course every animal has the right not to be eaten! They all deserve to be treated with respect and have the same right not to be killed as you and I do. Go ahead and prove me wrong, tell me animals don’t feel. Then go to your local slaughter house and work there for a couple of weeks, and tell me what you think.
And as for the first comment, no they don’t eat all that, they don’t even eat butter. Vegans aren’t hypocrites!
Of course you may decide what an animal deserves, that is if YOU own it.
If I own it, then I decide what it deserves.
If I hunt or fish, I am taking animals owned by the community at large (including you and me) and my share is determined by the bag and possession limit imposed by the state and federal governments.
If I raise chickens in my backyard I decide what makes the best meat and eggs for my family. In my case that means a fast humane kill because stressed animals taste less good. I also provide abundant water and healthy foods, because the eggs taste better and are more numerous that way.
If you decide to decapitate a lettuce for your salad denying yourself the animal proteins required by your body, so be it. I won’t stop you. HOWEVER, it is not your right to stop me from eating those nutritious and succulent meats if I want to eat them. Conversely, it is NOT my right to force you to eat beef.
I’ll go first. I promise not to make political actions to cause that force to happen to you. Now it is your turn to promise to do the same for me. To deny that is to deny that HUMANS have individual rights, even for yourself.
As an aside, no vegan has been able to describe for me why it is OK to kill a vegetable to eat it but not an animal. Still a life must end. Why the distinction?
Comments are moderated, and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. Extremely lengthy comments and those that contain obscenities may be edited before they are posted.
Add a comment:
I’m a good Christian father, happily married and have 8 children. I would like to know what is being done to protect veg. plants of all varieties?
After all they breathe air, drink water, need sunlight, fertilizer or not. Sounds a lot like farm animals to me!
Not to mention I bet the (veg.only people) drink milk,eat yogurt, cheese, sour cream, etc.
On a lighter note, do vegetarians eat animal crackers?
May GOD bless all
J. Morrison